PHOTOGRAPHY – Poverty & Property: The Claustrophobic Reality of HK Shoeboxes 25


Benny Lam’s photo series gives us a claustrophobic glimpse inside HK’s sub-divided ‘shoeboxes’…

nS1OXl.jpg (640×426)

The South China Morning Mouthpiece reports today that up to 280,000 Hong Kongers are living in subdivided flats and paying exorbitant rent…

s5fJKl.jpg (640×426)

Often these spaces are more expensive than their luxury equivalents. Monthly rent for such flats can be HK$27 per square foot, higher than the average HK$22.20 at 85 private housing developments (as reported by Centaline Property). As with many things, the poor pay more.

l5lKol.jpg (640×426)

Lethal fires are all too common, as the Wall St Journal reports in this article about the dangers of such set-ups…

XcDrg.jpg (555×394)

Via WSJ.com

Average home prices in Hong Kong have jumped 76% since the end of 2008. News outlets have been predicting a slow-down for many years (as recently as last week).

Click for high-res version

The photo project was organised in conjunction with SoCO – the Society for Community Organisation.

TVNqgl.jpg (640×426)

Less than 7% of Hong Kong’s land is designated for residential use, whilst some residents have been waiting years for public housing. Despite the conditions and illegal nature of subdivided dwellings, demand remains high.

They are typically seen in older buildings, which often have more relaxed property management. Such properties remain a lucrative investment for home owners. It emerged in August that the wife of the new Secretary for Development, Paul Chan Mo-po, owned subdivided flats…

HK has amongst the highest population densities in the world. Even HK’s last leader, Donald Tsang, admitted as he left office that ‘trickle down economics’ has failed the city’s poor

Arguably, those condemned to sub-divided living are the ‘lucky’ ones when compared to HK’s poorest, who reside in so-called ‘cage homes’ (CNN story, Daily Mail, BBC)…

HK is a wealthy place. With the highest concentration of millionaires in Asia, it is awash with luxury malls and sports cars. Yet the city lacks a proper social safety net, is home to the widest rich-poor gap in the developed world and has a minimum wage of just HK$30 (US$3.87 or £2.40 – as of May 2013). Around a tenth of families live in poverty, according to Oxfam…

rkJl0l.jpg (640×426)

Statistics from feedinghk.org

Pk3Hpl.png (640×436)

Click to enlarge

Click here for Michael Wolf’s ‘Architecture of Density’ series, which shows what some of the city’s ‘shoebox homes’ look like from the outside…

Click to see the photo series ‘Architecture of Density’

Click here to see the political art of Winnie Davies, which focuses on HK’s widening poverty gap.


  • http://dmix.ca dmix

    The poverty rates in HK are way lower than mainland china. How exactly has the HK economy “failed the poor” as their leader said?

    • Tom

      Because, with its GDP and status as a westernised ‘word city’, HK is usually compared with London, NY, Tokyo etc… as opposed to the ‘2nd world’ country on the doorstop.

      HK can more than afford for this not to be happening, but leaders choose to hand out HK$6k bail-outs indiscriminately, subsidise power bills or indulge in other corporatist cynical gestures.

  • https://dmix.ca dmix

    The poverty rates in HK are way lower than mainland china. How exactly has the HK economy “failed the poor” as their leader said?

    • Tom

      Because, with its GDP and status as a westernised ‘word city’, HK is usually compared with London, NY, Tokyo etc… as opposed to the ‘2nd world’ country on the doorstop.

      HK can more than afford for this not to be happening, but leaders choose to hand out HK$6k bail-outs indiscriminately, subsidise power bills or indulge in other corporatist cynical gestures.

    • Taro-nechan

      HK’s gini coefficient (53), which is a measure of income distribution is quite bad compared with the mainland (47), the mainland’s mini being quite bad by itself (Japan’s is 37).

      BTW, A gini coefficient of 100 means only 1 person, i.e. a monarch, controls all income in a country (100% of the income).

  • Pingback: PHOTOGRAPHY – Cages, Hookers, Tattoos: HK’s Grim Underbelly | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: Benny Lam – Photography – Poverty & Property: The Claustrophobic Reality of HK Shoeboxes

  • Pingback: Shoebox « cincincina

  • Pingback: Michael Wolf's 100x100 - Hong Kong Homes | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: Cramped Hong Kong |

  • Pingback: Aerial Shots of HK's Coffin Homes by Ko Chung Ming - hongwrong.com | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: the claustrophobic ‘shoebox’ | sentirsi a casa

  • Pingback: Cross-border tensions | Just another Hong Konger

  • Pingback: New Rules Make it Near Impossible for Hong Kong Domestic Maids to Quit | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: PHOTOGRAPHY - HK's Invisible Caged Poor: Mini Sculptures by Kwong Chi Kit | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: POLITICS – Revealed: CY Leung Met Tony Blair in Secretive June Meeting | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • Pingback: A tale of two streets | The Aberdeen Street Social

  • Truthseeker101

    Down with the capitalist system. Islamic finance is the solution.

  • Truthseeker101

    Down with the capitalist system. Islamic finance is the solution.

  • Pingback: Why Are Hong Kongers are Going Crazy for 'Lufsig' the Toy Wolf? | Hong Wrong Hong Kong Expat Blog

  • http://laukshoes.com/products_new.html laukshoes.com New

    Seth Meyers, former SNL star and current host of Late Night, has been given yet another venue to make us laugh, as he’s been tapped to host the 2014 Primetime Emmys.

  • http://utesgold.tumblr.com/ eso gold

    a lot of these eso gold are fantastic you will find imagined these for quite a while these days in conclusion became these when it comes to christmas they are so pleasant, search good quality with the help of blue-jean. since i wish to offer spa skirts they will look fantastic less than the whole bunch. everyone loves convenience along with the eso gold tend to be so what i am searching for. could very well individuals throughout blackberry mobile phones wine beverages . i absolutly adoration him or her and so the tone!!

  • http://esogolds.tumblr.com/ eso gold

    These start looking so great and feel so good. I want to bring eso gold on a regular basis, ! I just might have to purchase a further coloration ….

  • http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html cheap burberry handbags

    Forecasted guys closing rankings: [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]burberry outlet[/url]
    At the end of your 14-week competitors, the superior 10 squads arrive at stop by Washington, D.H. to meet up with the adviser and attend a great accolades reception into their recognition. [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]cheap burberry outlet[/url]
    Well Resize [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]cheap burberry outlet[/url]
    Ofobike will be the Shining example Log key content author. She may always be arrived at from 330-996-3513 or by means of mail with . [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]cheap burberry bags[/url]
    Classifieds classified ads [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]cheap burberry bags[/url]
    E: In training inside an unforgiving local climate much like the wasteland can in which benefit your endurance? [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]burberry outlet online[/url]
    From the glass-fronted veranda, I actually keep an eye out within the Bosphorus Strait, an essential shipment route involving the Black color Ocean and the Seashore involving Marmara which often divides the town among Western side and Distance, Europe and Asia. [url=http://www.hotelwestpoint.com/burbsoutlets.html]burberry outlet[/url]
    “The NCAA disciplined this soccer enter in March This year having a time of year pan exclude as well as scholarship grant… View A lot more Submitted through twatts1000

  • Pingback: Villagers of Ma Shi Po Fight Hong Kong's Big Developers